18 Highlights 61 Differences 2 Reactions 0 Likes

Etekcity ESF17 vs Withings Body Scan: 18 Highlights & 61 Differences — So, Which Smart Scale Actually Works Better

Learn about build quality, connectivity, and health ecosystem integration at a glance. Gadget showdown: Etekcity ESF17 vs Withings Body Scan &#8212 see how they match up in performance, features, and user data control options, regulatory compliance, cleaning method & calibration maintenance need.

0 Points
Etekcity ESF17
0 Points
Withings Body Scan
vs

Highlights 153

No extras. Just what matters.
0 Points
vs
0 Points

Why is Etekcity ESF17 better than Withings Body Scan ?

Scroll down for more facts

Smart Scale Showdown: Etekcity ESF17 vs Withings Body Scan

When diving into the world of smart scales, the Etekcity ESF17 and Withings Body Scan both offer comprehensive body composition tracking tailored to health and fitness enthusiasts. Both devices provide essential metrics such as weight, body fat, BMI, muscle and bone mass, hydration, visceral fat, and metabolic age, ensuring users have a solid understanding of their physical wellness. They are designed for home use in environments like bathrooms and home gyms and require companion apps for data visualization and management.

Despite these overlaps, the difference between them lies in their target audiences, sensor sophistication, connectivity features, and overall user experience. While the Etekcity ESF17 is a budget-friendly Bluetooth smart scale focusing on core metrics with straightforward data syncing via the VeSync app, the Withings Body Scan steps up with hybrid sensor technology, multi-user profiles, advanced measurements including heart rate and segmental body analysis, and Wi-Fi plus Bluetooth connectivity for seamless integration into a broader health ecosystem.

Why the Etekcity ESF17 Can Be a Great Smart Scale for Everyday Fitness

The Etekcity ESF17 shines as an approachable and dependable smart scale for users who want to keep track of the fundamentals without breaking the bank. Constructed from glass and plastic with a glossy finish and good build quality, it provides a low-profile, lightweight design (just 4.6 lbs) with rubberized foot grips and anti-slip feet for stability.

The scale's maximum weight capacity of 400 lbs covers most users comfortably, while the bright, high-resolution LED display with blue backlight ensures clear readings. Although it doesn't have touch controls, the embedded display is well-integrated for ease of use.

Measurement reliability is strong for weight (high accuracy) and stable for body fat (medium accuracy), thanks to itsfour4 bioelectrical impedance sensors and advanced signal stability tech like motion filtering, auto-calibration, and zero-reset functions. Users enjoy multiple profiles, automatic user recognition, and even athlete and guest modes, all managed via the user-friendly VeSync app, syncing via Bluetooth 5.0.

For power, it relies on a long-life lithium-ion battery that requires no recharge time, and it efficiently conserves energy with features like auto power off. The scale supports major health platforms, including Apple Health and Google Fit, plus voice commands for Alexa, Google Assistant, and Siri, although it lacks Wi-Fi or smart home integration. All these factors make it a winner for straightforward fitness tracking at a bargain price; it is currently available for just $32.99 at etekcity.com.

The Withings Body Scan: For Those Who Demand Precision and Full-Scale Wellness Insights

On the other end of the spectrum, the Withings Body Scan is a premium hybrid smart scale released more recently, engineered with higher-grade materials like aluminum, steel, plastic, and tempered glass with a matte finish that feels both durable and sleek. Its larger, heavier footprint (9.7 lbs) supports a maximum weight capacity of 440 kg, accommodating a wider range of users.

Display-wise, it boasts a clear white backlit LED with touch control and user indicator icons that enrich the interface experience. The scale employs multiple sensor technologies, including strain gauges and sophisticated electrodes made of stainless steel and conductive alloys, enabling highly accurate, high-precision weight and body fat readings with more consistent repeatability.

This model advances body composition analysis with features such as heart rate measurement, segmental body analysis, and subcutaneous fat estimation, plus specific modes designed for pregnancy and child use, a testament to its versatility and clinical-level monitoring. The Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connectivity provide seamless, real-time data syncing with the proprietary Withings app, which includes advanced dashboards, trends, insights, and rich data visualization backed by long-term retention and export options.

Moreover, it integrates with the Apple Watch and offers a sophisticated health ecosystem with smart home ecosystem compatibility. The rechargeable lithium-ion battery charges via USB-C, ensuring extended usage and easy top-ups, supported by energy-efficient design features. Security is another elevated point, carrying industry-certified data protection in line with GDPR and CCPA.

The Withings Body Scan's premium build, advanced technologies, and comprehensive feature set justify its $399.95 price at stores like Amazon and Best Buy, making it ideal for the health-conscious user who values detailed metrics and professional-grade data.

Quick Take

The Etekcity ESF17 delivers excellent value for basic yet reliable smart scale needs, especially suited to those wanting key body metrics without costly extras. In contrast, the Withings Body Scan is an all-in-one health monitoring powerhouse that blends premium build and cutting-edge features for users who want a deep dive into body analytics and wider health ecosystem integration.

Bottom Line

If your priority is budget-conscious, precise daily fitness tracking with a straightforward interface, the Etekcity ESF17 is a compelling choice. However, if you seek comprehensive body composition analysis, clinical-grade accuracy, and extensive connectivity features, investing in the Withings Body Scan will reward you with a sophisticated and versatile health device that goes far beyond basics.

Verdict

  • Winner: Withings Body Scan - for its advanced sensor technology, detailed measurement capabilities, and superior connectivity, making it a leader in smart scale innovation.
  • Runner-up: Etekcity ESF17 - for providing essential health tracking at an unbeatable price point with reliable performance and accessible app features.

Comparisons 13

Two enter. One leaves your cart.

Price comparisons

(✱) Prices may be changed at any time without further notice.

Related comparisons 13

Because one duel is never enough.

Comparisons & Facts 153

Side by side. The numbers. The features. No drama.

From feature sets to real-life wins and flaws, this smart scales comparison between Etekcity ESF17 and Withings Body Scan helps you cut through the noise.

General Information 10

Environment Suitability

Where can this smart scale be used?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Bathroom, Home Gym

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Bathroom, Home Gym, Clinic

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Environment Suitability

The Environment Suitability for Etekcity ESF17 is Bathroom, Home Gym, while Withings Body Scan can be used in Bathroom, Home Gym, Clinic.

Indicates suitable environments for safe and effective use.

Smart Scale Type

What type of smart scale is this?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Bluetooth Smart Scale

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Hybrid Smart Scale

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Smart Scale Type

The Smart Scale Type for Etekcity ESF17 is Bluetooth Smart Scale, while for Withings Body Scan it is Hybrid Smart Scale.

Indicates how the smart scale connects and operates.

Intended Use Case

What is the main use case of this smart scale?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Body Composition Tracking, Fitness Monitoring

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Body Composition Tracking, Fitness Monitoring, Health Monitoring

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Intended Use Case

Etekcity ESF17 is designed for Body Composition Tracking and Fitness Monitoring, in contrast to Withings Body Scan which includes Health Monitoring as well.

Explains the main purpose of the smart scale.

Subscription Required

Is a subscription required to use all features?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Subscription Required

Etekcity ESF17 does not require a subscription, whereas Withings Body Scan does require a subscription.

Shows whether a paid subscription is needed for full functionality.

Health Ecosystem Category

Which health ecosystem does this smart scale belong to?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Fitness, Wellness

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Fitness, Wellness, Medical

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Health Ecosystem Category

In the Health Ecosystem Category, Etekcity ESF17 is categorized as Fitness, Wellness, whereas Withings Body Scan includes Fitness, Wellness, Medical.

Places the product within a broader health context.

Intended Measurement Purpose

What measurements is this smart scale intended to provide?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Weight Only, Full Body Metrics, Health Insights

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Full Body Metrics

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Intended Measurement Purpose

The Intended Measurement Purpose of Etekcity ESF17 is Weight Only, while Withings Body Scan serves Full Body Metrics.

Defines the scope of measurements provided.

Target User

Who is this smart scale designed for?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes General Adult, Family

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes General Adult, Athlete, Family

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Target User

The Target User for Etekcity ESF17 is General Adult, Family, whereas Withings Body Scan caters to General Adult, Athlete, Family.

Describes the primary intended user group.

User Skill Level

What user skill level is this smart scale designed for?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Beginner

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Beginner

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
User Skill Level

Both Etekcity ESF17 and Withings Body Scan are suitable for Beginners in User Skill Level.

Indicates how easy the scale is to use.

Release Year

What year was this smart scale released?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes 2018

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes 2023

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Release Year

Etekcity ESF17 was released in 2018, whereas Withings Body Scan was released in 2023.

Shows how recent the product generation is.

App Required

Is an app required to use this smart scale?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
App Required

Both products require an app, as Etekcity ESF17 has App Required as Yes and so does Withings Body Scan.

Indicates whether an app is mandatory for use.

Design & Build 12

Surface Texture

What is the surface texture like?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Smooth

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Smooth

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Surface Texture

The Surface Texture of the Etekcity ESF17 is Smooth, while Withings Body Scan is also Smooth.

Indicates how the platform surface feels underfoot.

Anti-Slip Feet

Does the scale have anti-slip feet?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Anti-Slip Feet

Both Etekcity ESF17 and Withings Body Scan have Anti-Slip Feet.

Indicates whether the scale includes anti-slip feet.

Body Material

What material is the scale body made of?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Glass, Plastic

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Plastic, Aluminum, Steel, Glass

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Body Material

The Body Material of Etekcity ESF17 is made from Glass, Plastic, while that of Withings Body Scan includes Plastic, Aluminum, Steel, Glass.

Defines the primary material used for the scale body.

Finish Type

What type of finish does the scale have?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Glossy

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Matte

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Finish Type

The Finish Type for Etekcity ESF17 is Glossy, whereas Withings Body Scan features a Matte finish.

Describes the surface finish of the scale.

Build Quality

How is the build quality of the smart scale?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Good

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Premium

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Build Quality

Etekcity ESF17 has Good Build Quality, while Withings Body Scan boasts Premium Build Quality.

Describes the overall construction quality, material feel, and perceived durability of the smart scale.

Form Factor

What is the form factor of the scale?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Low-Profile

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Flat

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Form Factor

The Form Factor of Etekcity ESF17 is Low-Profile, while Withings Body Scan has a Flat form factor.

Defines the overall shape and height profile.

Platform Material

What is the platform material?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Tempered Glass, Plastic, Composite, Steel

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Tempered Glass

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Platform Material

Etekcity ESF17’s Platform Material consists of Tempered Glass, Plastic, Composite, Steel, while Withings Body Scan uses Tempered Glass.

Specifies the surface material users stand on.

Color Options

What color options are available?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Black

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Black, White, Gray, Silver, Blue

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Color Options

Etekcity ESF17 offers Color Options in Black, while Withings Body Scan includes Black, White, Gray, Silver, Blue.

Indicates available color variants.

Edge Design

What type of edge design does the scale use?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Rounded

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Rounded

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Edge Design

Both products have Rounded Edge Design.

Describes the shape and contour of the scale edges.

Foot Grip Type

What type of foot grip does the scale use?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Rubberized

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes None

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Foot Grip Type

Etekcity ESF17 features a Rubberized Foot Grip Type, whereas Withings Body Scan has None.

Specifies the grip material used on the base.

Footprint Size

How large is the footprint size?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Standard

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Standard

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Footprint Size

The Footprint Size for both products is Standard.

Describes how much floor space the smart scale occupies during use.

Display Integration Style

How is the display integrated into the scale?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Embedded

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Embedded

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Display Integration Style

Etekcity ESF17 features an Embedded Display Integration Style, which is also true for Withings Body Scan.

Describes how the display is integrated into the platform.

Dimensions & Weight 9

Product Weight

How much does the smart scale weigh?

4.6 lbs 0 Votes
9.7 lbs 0 Votes

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Product Weight

The Product Weight for Etekcity ESF17 is 4.6 lbs, in contrast to Withings Body Scan's weight of 9.7 lbs.

Weight of the smart scale itself.

Depth

What is the depth of the smart scale?

12.2 inch 0 Votes
12.8 inch 0 Votes

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Depth

The Depth of Etekcity ESF17 is 12.2 inches, while Withings Body Scan has a Depth of 12.8 inches.

Measures the front-to-back size of the scale.

Height

What is the height of the smart scale?

1 inch 0 Votes
1.1 inch 0 Votes

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Height

Etekcity ESF17 has a Height of 1 inch, while Withings Body Scan stands at 1.1 inches tall.

Shows how tall the scale sits off the floor.

Package Depth

What is the package depth?

13.2 inch 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Package Depth

Etekcity ESF17's Package Depth is 13.2 inches, while Withings Body Scan's Package Depth value is unavailable.

Depth of the retail packaging.

Maximum User Weight Capacity

What is the maximum supported user weight?

400 lbs 0 Votes
440 lbs 0 Votes

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Maximum User Weight Capacity

Etekcity ESF17 supports a Maximum User Weight Capacity of 400 lbs, whereas Withings Body Scan's capacity is 440 lbs.

Maximum supported user weight for safe operation.

Width

What is the width of the smart scale?

12.2 inch 0 Votes
12.8 inch 0 Votes

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Width

In terms of Width, Etekcity ESF17 measures 12.2 inches compared to Withings Body Scan's 12.8 inches.

Indicates the left-to-right size of the scale footprint.

Package Width

What is the package width?

13.4 inch 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Package Width

Etekcity ESF17's Package Width is 13.4 inches, whereas Withings Body Scan's Package Width value is unavailable.

Width of the retail packaging.

Package Height

What is the package height?

2.5 inch 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Package Height

Etekcity ESF17's Package Height is 2.5 inches, whereas Withings Body Scan's Package Height value is unavailable.

Height of the retail packaging.

Package Weight

What is the package weight?

5.5 lbs 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Package Weight

Etekcity ESF17 has a Package Weight of 5.5 lbs, while Withings Body Scan's Package Weight is unavailable.

Total shipping weight including packaging.

Display & Interface 11

Language Support

What languages are supported on the display?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes English, Spanish, French, German

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes English, Spanish, French, German

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The device and its accompanying app support multiple languages, including English, Spanish, French, and German, catering to a diverse user base.

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The device supports multiple languages, including English, Spanish, French, and German, catering to a diverse user base.

Indicates supported display languages.

Display Type

What type of display does the smart scale use?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes LED

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes LED

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Display Type

The Display Type for both Etekcity ESF17 and Withings Body Scan is LED.

Specifies the technology used for the on-scale display.

Backlight Type

What backlight color does the display use?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Blue

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes White

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Backlight Type

Etekcity ESF17 has a Blue Backlight Type, compared to Withings Body Scan which has White.

Defines the color of the display backlight.

Button Type

What type of buttons does the scale use?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes None

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes None

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Button Type

Both Etekcity ESF17 and Withings Body Scan use None as Button Type.

Specifies the type of physical or virtual buttons used.

Display Size

What is the display size?

3.5 inch 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Display Size

Etekcity ESF17 has a Display Size of 3.5 inches, while Withings Body Scan's Display Size value is unavailable.

Indicates the diagonal size of the display area.

Display Resolution

How clear is the display resolution?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes High

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes High

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Display Resolution

Both products feature a High Display Resolution.

Indicates the clarity and sharpness of characters and numbers shown on the display.

Brightness Level

How bright is the display?

50 dB 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Brightness Level

Etekcity ESF17 has a Brightness Level of 50 dB, while brightness level for Withings Body Scan is unavailable.

Represents the intensity of display illumination.

Visibility Angle

What is the display visibility angle?

160 degree 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Visibility Angle

The Visibility Angle of Etekcity ESF17 is 160 degrees, while that of Withings Body Scan is also unavailable.

Indicates how well the display can be read from different angles.

Touch Control

Does the display support touch controls?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Touch Control

Etekcity ESF17 does not have Touch Control, whereas Withings Body Scan does.

Indicates whether the display supports touch input.

Indicator Icons

What indicator icons are shown on the display?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Bluetooth, Battery

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Bluetooth, Battery, User

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
Indicator Icons

Etekcity ESF17 has Indicator Icons as Bluetooth, Battery while Withings Body Scan includes Bluetooth, Battery, User.

Lists icons shown for system status.

On-Device Feedback Type

What type of feedback does the scale provide?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Visual, Audio, Haptic

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Visual, Audio, Haptic

Etekcity ESF17
vs
Withings Body Scan
On-Device Feedback Type

On-Device Feedback for Etekcity ESF17 includes Visual, Audio, Haptic while Withings Body Scan offers the same.

Describes feedback methods provided directly by the scale.

Sensors & Measurement Hardware 11

Pressure Sensor Technology

What pressure sensor technology is used?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Load Cell

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Load Cell

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The scale utilizes Load Cell technology for pressure sensing, which is a common and reliable method for precise weight measurement in consumer scales.

Describes how weight pressure is detected.

Bioelectrical Impedance

Does the scale support bioelectrical impedance?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The scale uses Bioelectrical Impedance (BIA) technology to estimate various body composition metrics by sending a small electrical current through the body.

Indicates support for body composition measurement via impedance.

Measurement Sampling Rate

What is the measurement sampling rate?

10 Hz 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The measurement sampling rate is 10 Hz, meaning the scale takes 10 readings per second for accurate and responsive data capture.

Frequency at which sensor data is sampled.

Signal Stability Technology

How does the scale stabilize sensor signals?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Motion Filtering

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Motion Filtering

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The scale employs Motion Filtering as a signal stability technology, which helps to reduce inaccuracies caused by slight movements during measurement. This ensures more reliable readings.

Describes methods used to stabilize readings.

Sensor Lifespan Rating

How long is the sensor lifespan expected to last?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Long

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Long

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The sensors in the scale have a Long lifespan rating, ensuring durable and consistent performance over many years of use. This contributes to the product's overall reliability.

Describes the expected durability and operational lifespan of the internal sensors under normal usage conditions.

Sensor Type

What type of sensors does the smart scale use?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Bioelectrical Impedance

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Strain Gauge, Bioelectrical Impedance

Identifies the primary sensing technologies used.

Number of Sensors

How many sensors does the scale use?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes 4

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Multiple

Indicates how many sensors are embedded in the scale.

Electrode Material

What material are the electrodes made from?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes ITO Coating

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Stainless Steel, ITO Coating, Conductive Alloy

Specifies the material used for impedance electrodes.

Auto-Calibration

Does the scale support auto-calibration?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether the scale self-calibrates automatically.

Zero-Reset Function

Does the scale support zero-reset?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates ability to reset baseline weight to zero.

Measurement Start Method

How does the scale start a measurement?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Step-On

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Step-On

Describes how measurements are initiated.

Measured Body Metrics 16

Body Fat Percentage

Does the scale measure body fat percentage?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

This smart scale measures body fat percentage, which is a key indicator of overall health and fitness. It helps users track their body composition beyond just total weight.

Indicates support for body fat percentage calculation.

Heart Rate Measurement

Does the scale measure heart rate?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether heart rate is measured during use.

Segmental Body Analysis

Does the scale support segmental analysis?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates support for segment-by-segment body analysis.

Trend Analysis

Does the scale support trend analysis?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether long-term trends are tracked.

Weight Measurement

Does the scale measure body weight?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The device is capable of providing accurate weight measurements, which is its primary function as a smart scale.

Indicates whether the scale measures body weight.

Bone Mass

Does the scale measure bone mass?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The scale can measure bone mass, providing an estimation of the total weight of bone mineral in your body. This metric can be an indicator of overall bone health.

Indicates whether bone mass is estimated.

Subcutaneous Fat

Does the scale measure subcutaneous fat?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The scale provides measurements for subcutaneous fat, which is the fat stored directly under the skin. Tracking this can help users understand their body composition more comprehensively.

Indicates support for subcutaneous fat estimation.

Lean Body Mass

Does the scale measure lean body mass?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The scale can estimate lean body mass, which represents the total weight of your body minus all the fat mass.

Indicates whether lean body mass is provided.

Protein Percentage

Does the scale estimate protein percentage?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The scale can estimate protein percentage in the body, which is a useful metric for assessing muscle health and dietary intake. This provides a more comprehensive view of body composition.

Indicates whether body protein percentage is estimated.

Body Type Classification

Does the scale classify body type?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The scale offers body type classification, categorizing users based on their body composition metrics. This can provide personalized feedback and insights tailored to individual physiques.

Indicates whether body type categories are provided.

Body Mass Index

Does the scale calculate BMI?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether BMI is calculated.

Muscle Mass

Does the scale measure muscle mass?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether muscle mass is measured.

Accuracy & Performance 10

Weight Measurement Accuracy

How accurate is the weight measurement?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes High

0 Withings Body Scan 1 Votes High

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

This device offers High weight measurement accuracy, ensuring precise and reliable readings for effective health tracking. Users can trust the consistency of their weight data.

Describes the overall accuracy level of weight measurements rather than a numeric margin.

The weight measurement accuracy is spot on in both but I trust the Withings more for consistent reads.

See more

Repeatability Consistency

How consistent are repeated measurements?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes High

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes High

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The scale demonstrates High repeatability consistency, ensuring that repeated measurements under the same conditions yield very similar results. This indicates excellent reliability.

Indicates consistency across repeated measurements.

Environmental Drift Compensation

Does the scale compensate for environmental drift?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

This feature compensates for environmental factors that might affect measurement accuracy, such as temperature fluctuations. It ensures consistent readings regardless of minor changes in its surroundings.

Indicates compensation for temperature or surface changes.

Body Fat Accuracy

How accurate is the body fat measurement?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Medium

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes High

Indicates the overall reliability level of body fat percentage estimation provided by the smart scale.

Measurement Resolution

What is the measurement resolution?

0.2 lbs 0 Votes
0.1 lbs 0 Votes

Smallest detectable change in measurement value.

Stabilization Time

How long does stabilization take?

3 second 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Time required for readings to stabilize.

Error Margin Disclosure

Is the error margin disclosed?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

No 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether accuracy margins are disclosed by the manufacturer.

Auto User Recognition Accuracy

How accurate is automatic user recognition?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Medium

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes High

Describes how reliably the smart scale can automatically identify the correct user profile based on measurement data.

Performance Consistency Rating

How consistent is overall performance?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Good

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Excellent

Overall consistency rating across conditions.

Measurement Confidence Indicator

Does the scale show measurement confidence indicators?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether the scale shows confidence or validation cues.

Connectivity & App Features 14

Voice Assistant

Does the scale support voice assistants?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Alexa, Google Assistant, Siri

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Alexa

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The smart scale integrates with Alexa voice assistant, allowing users to interact with their health data or retrieve information using voice commands.

Indicates compatibility with voice assistants.

Wi-Fi Connectivity

Does the scale support Wi-Fi?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether the scale can connect directly to Wi-Fi.

Smart Home Integration

Does the scale support smart home integration?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether the scale integrates with smart home systems.

Wireless Connectivity Type

What wireless connectivity does the scale support?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Bluetooth

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Wi-Fi, Bluetooth

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The scale offers dual wireless connectivity, supporting both Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. This ensures versatile data synchronization options, allowing for real-time updates and broad compatibility.

Defines the wireless technologies used for data transfer.

Bluetooth Version

What Bluetooth version does the smart scale use?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Bluetooth 5.0

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Bluetooth 5.0

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The scale utilizes Bluetooth 5.0 for wireless connectivity, offering improved speed, range, and energy efficiency compared to older Bluetooth versions.

Indicates the Bluetooth standard used for wireless communication with mobile devices, affecting range, stability, and power efficiency.

App Name

What is the name of the companion app?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes VeSync

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Withings App

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

The companion application for this smart scale is known as the Withings App, serving as the central hub for tracking and analyzing all health metrics.

Identifies the companion mobile application.

Real-Time Sync

Does the scale support real-time syncing?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

Real-time synchronization is supported, meaning your measurements are instantly transferred to the connected app as you use the scale.

Indicates whether data syncs immediately after measurement.

Cloud Sync

Does the scale support cloud sync?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

Cloud synchronization is supported, securely storing your health data online for access from any device and ensuring data backup. This allows for seamless data management and recovery.

Indicates whether data is backed up to the cloud.

Firmware Update Method

How are firmware updates applied?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes App-Based

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes App-Based

Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan

Firmware updates are delivered via an App-Based method, allowing for convenient and automatic updates through the connected mobile application. This ensures the device always has the latest features and improvements.

Describes how firmware updates are delivered.

App Feature Set

What features does the app provide?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Trends, Goals

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Dashboards, Trends, Goals, Insights

Describes the core features available in the app.

Offline Measurement Storage

Can the scale store data offline?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether measurements are stored without connectivity.

Data Sync Speed

How fast does data sync to the app?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Fast

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Fast

Describes how quickly data syncs to the app.

User Profiles & Data Handling 10

Maximum User Profiles

How many user profiles can the scale support?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes unlimited

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes 8

Maximum number of individual user profiles supported.

Automatic User Detection

Does the scale automatically detect users?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether the scale can identify users automatically.

Athlete Mode

Does the scale support athlete mode?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates specialized algorithms for athletic users.

Pregnancy Mode

Does the scale include pregnancy mode?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether pregnancy-safe measurement logic is available.

Data Visualization Type

How is user data visualized?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Charts, Trends

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Charts, Graphs, Trends

Describes how data is visually presented.

Guest Mode

Does the scale support guest mode?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

A guest mode is available, allowing temporary users to take measurements without having their data saved to a permanent profile.

Indicates support for temporary, non-stored measurements.

Profile Switching Method

How do users switch profiles?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Automatic

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Automatic

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The scale automatically detects the user, simplifying the process of tracking individual health metrics without manual selection.

Describes how users switch between profiles.

Data Export

Can users export their data?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The smart scale supports data export, allowing users to transfer their measurement data to other applications or for backup purposes.

Indicates whether user data can be exported externally.

Child Mode

Does the scale include a child mode?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether measurements are adapted for children.

Historical Data Retention

How long is historical data retained?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Long-Term

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Long-Term

Describes how long user measurement history is stored and accessible within the system.

Power & Battery 10

Standby Power Consumption

How much power is used in standby?

0.1 Watt 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

In standby mode, the device consumes only 0.1 Watt of power, ensuring energy efficiency and extending battery life.

Power usage while idle or in standby mode.

Battery Capacity

How large is the battery capacity?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes High

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes High

Indicates the relative energy storage capacity of the battery rather than a numeric value.

Charging Method

How is the scale charged?

Who knows? 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes USB-C

Describes how the battery is recharged.

Power Efficiency Rating

How efficient is the scale’s power usage?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes High

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes High

Overall efficiency of power usage.

Battery Life

How long does the battery last?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Long

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Long

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The scale offers Long battery life, minimizing the frequency of battery replacements and ensuring extended usage.

Describes how long the smart scale can operate before requiring battery replacement or recharging.

Charging Time

How long does it take to charge?

0 hour 0 Votes

Who knows? 0 Votes Withings Body Scan (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The charging time for this scale is 0 hour, which indicates it operates on non-rechargeable batteries and does not require charging.

Time required to fully charge the battery.

Low Battery Indicator

Does the scale show a low battery warning?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

A low battery indicator is present, alerting users when the scale's battery needs replacement or recharging.

Indicates whether a low battery warning is provided.

Power Source Type

What is the power source type?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Battery

0 Withings Body Scan 1 Votes Rechargeable Battery

Defines how the smart scale is powered.

Battery wise the Etekcity uses standard batteries which is fine but Withings has a rechargeable one which is pretty convenient.

See more

Battery Type

What type of battery does the scale use?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Lithium-Ion

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Lithium-Ion

Specifies the type of battery used.

Auto Power Off

Does the scale power off automatically?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates automatic shutdown to conserve power.

Compatibility & Integration 9

Multi-Account

Does the scale support multiple accounts?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The scale supports multiple user accounts, allowing different family members to track their individual health data separately within the same app.

Indicates support for multiple user accounts.

Third-Party App Compatibility

Does the scale support third-party apps?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates support for external health or fitness apps.

Operating System Compatibility

Which operating systems are supported?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes iOS, Android

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes iOS, Android

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The smart scale is compatible with both iOS and Android mobile operating systems, allowing a wide range of smartphone users to connect and utilize the companion app.

Specifies supported mobile operating systems.

Smartphone Compatibility

Is the scale compatible with smartphones?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The smart scale offers full compatibility with smartphones, enabling seamless data synchronization and advanced feature access through its dedicated mobile application.

Indicates whether smartphones are supported.

Tablet Compatibility

Is the scale compatible with tablets?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The smart scale is compatible with tablets, allowing users to view and track their health metrics on a larger screen through the companion app.

Indicates whether tablets can be used with the scale.

Minimum OS Version Requirement

What is the minimum OS version required?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes 10.0+

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes iOS 14 / Android 9

Defines the minimum operating system version required.

Wearable Ecosystem Compatibility

Which wearables are supported?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Apple Health, Fitness Trackers, Smart Bands

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Apple Watch, Apple Health, Fitness Trackers

Indicates compatibility with wearable ecosystems.

Account Login Requirement

Is account login required?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether an account is required for use.

Regional Availability Support

In which regions is the scale supported?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes North America, Europe, Asia-Pacific

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes North America, Europe

Indicates supported regions and localization.

Privacy & Security 9

User Data Control Options

What control do users have over their data?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes View, Edit, Delete, Export

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes View, Edit, Delete, Export

Describes what actions users can take on their data.

Regulatory Compliance

Which regulations does the scale comply with?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes GDPR, CCPA

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes GDPR, CCPA

Indicates compliance with data protection regulations.

Account Authentication Method

How do users authenticate their account?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Password

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Password

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

User accounts are secured using a Password as the primary authentication method, ensuring privacy for personal health data.

Describes how users authenticate their accounts.

Data Encryption

Is user data encrypted?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether user data is encrypted during storage and transfer.

Local Data Storage Option

Can data be stored locally?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether data can be stored locally on the device or phone.

Cloud Data Storage Location

Where is cloud data stored?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Global Cloud

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Global Cloud

Describes where user data is stored when cloud synchronization is enabled.

Privacy Policy Transparency

Is the privacy policy transparent?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether privacy practices are clearly disclosed.

Data Deletion

Can users delete their data?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether users can delete their data permanently.

Security Certification

What level of security certification is provided?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Basic Compliance

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Industry Certified

Indicates the level of formal security or data protection certification associated with the product or platform.

Environmental & Durability 8

Impact Resistance

How impact-resistant is the scale?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Low

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Moderate

Describes resistance to accidental drops or impacts.

Operating Temperature Range

What temperature range can the scale operate in?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes 41-104°F

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes 50-104°F

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

This device is designed to operate reliably within a temperature range of 41-104°F, which translates to 5-40°C, ensuring optimal performance in typical indoor environments.

Defines the temperature conditions under which the scale operates reliably.

Durability Rating

How durable is the scale?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes High

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes High

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

The scale has a High durability rating, indicating it is built to withstand regular use and maintain performance over time.

Overall assessment of long-term durability.

Operating Humidity Range

What humidity range is supported?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes 20-80%

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes 20-80%

Indicates acceptable humidity levels for operation.

Water Resistance Rating

Does the scale have water resistance?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes None

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes None

Indicates protection against water splashes or moisture.

Dust Resistance Rating

Does the scale resist dust?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes None

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes None

Indicates resistance to dust ingress.

Floor Surface Compatibility

What floor surfaces are compatible?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Tile, Wood, Concrete

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Tile, Wood, Concrete

Indicates which floor types support accurate readings.

Environmental Material Safety

Are the materials environmentally safe?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates use of non-toxic and compliant materials.

Maintenance & Care 6

Cleaning Method

How should the smart scale be cleaned?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Damp Cloth

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Dry Wipe

Describes the recommended way to clean the scale safely.

Calibration Maintenance Need

Does the scale require manual calibration?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

No 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether manual recalibration is needed over time.

Maintenance Frequency

How often does the scale need maintenance?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Low

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Moderate

Indicates how often maintenance is required.

Surface Coating Protection

Does the scale have surface coating protection?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether protective coatings resist scratches or stains.

Firmware Maintenance Requirement

Does the scale require firmware maintenance?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether regular firmware updates are required.

Long-Term Reliability Expectation

How reliable is the scale long term?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Medium

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes High

Expected reliability over extended use.

In the Box & Support 8

Customer Support Channels

What customer support channels are available?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Email, Chat, Phone, Help Center

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Email, Chat, Help Center

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17

Comprehensive customer support is available through multiple channels, including Email, Chat, Phone, and an online Help Center, to assist with any product inquiries.

Lists available customer support contact methods.

Included Accessories

What accessories are included?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Batteries, User Manual, Quick Start Guide

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Charging Cable, User Manual

Lists additional accessories included in the box.

Power Accessories

Are power accessories included in the box?

No 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether batteries or charging cables are included.

User Manual

Is a user manual included?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether a full user manual is provided.

Quick Start Guide

Is a quick start guide included?

Yes 0 Votes Etekcity ESF17

Yes 0 Votes Withings Body Scan

Indicates whether a quick start guide is provided.

Warranty Length

How long is the warranty?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes 2 Years

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes 1 Year

Length of manufacturer warranty coverage.

Software Support Duration

How long is software support provided?

5 year 0 Votes
5 year 0 Votes

Duration of software and app support updates.

Return Policy

What is the return policy?

0 Etekcity ESF17 0 Votes Standard Returns

0 Withings Body Scan 0 Votes Standard Returns

Describes the terms, duration, and conditions under which the product can be returned or refunded after purchase.

Surveys

Because hot takes deserve votes.

Weight Measurement Accuracy

How accurate is the weight measurement on this smart scale during daily use?

Extremely precise — Within 0.1 lb difference
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Very accurate — Within 0.2 lb difference
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Accurate enough — Within 0.5 lb difference
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Noticeably inconsistent — Within 1 lb difference
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Hard to trust — Over 1 lb difference
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan

Body Composition Accuracy

How accurate is the body composition data from this smart scale?

Highly accurate — Consistent and repeatable results
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Mostly accurate — Small variations between readings
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Moderately accurate — Useful for trends only
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Low accuracy — Large reading fluctuations
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Unreliable — Results feel random
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan

Measurement Speed

How quickly does this smart scale complete a full measurement?

Instant — Under 3 seconds
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Very fast — 3 to 5 seconds
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Acceptable — 5 to 8 seconds
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Slow — 8 to 12 seconds
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Very slow — Over 12 seconds
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan

App Usability

How easy is the app to use with this smart scale?

Very intuitive — Easy navigation and clear data
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Mostly simple — Minor learning curve
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Usable — Requires time to get used to
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Confusing — Features hard to find
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Frustrating — Poor layout and bugs
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan

Setup Experience

How smooth is the initial setup process for this smart scale?

Effortless — Ready in under 5 minutes
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Easy — Simple steps with guidance
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Moderate — Some trial and error
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Difficult — Setup takes time
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Frustrating — Setup issues or failures
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan

Connectivity Stability

How reliable is the wireless connection on this smart scale?

Very stable — Connects every time
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Mostly stable — Rare disconnects
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Inconsistent — Occasional dropouts
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Unstable — Frequent connection issues
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Unreliable — Often fails to connect
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan

Multi User Recognition

How well does this smart scale recognize different users automatically?

Perfect recognition — No mix ups at all
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Very good — Rare incorrect assignments
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Acceptable — Manual correction needed sometimes
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Poor — Frequent user mix ups
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Very poor — Cannot reliably identify users
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan

Build Quality

How solid and durable does this smart scale feel during use?

Premium feel — Very sturdy materials
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Well built — Solid and reliable
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Average — Feels okay for daily use
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Flimsy — Light and less durable
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Cheap — Feels fragile
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan

Battery Life

How long does this smart scale run before batteries need replacement or recharging?

Very long — Over 12 months
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Long — 9 to 12 months
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Average — 6 to 9 months
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Short — 3 to 6 months
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Very short — Under 3 months
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan

Pricing

How does the price of this smart scale feel compared to its features?

Excellent value — Worth every penny
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Good value — Fair for the features
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Reasonable — Matches expectations
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Expensive — Feels overpriced
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan
Very expensive — Hard to justify
0 Votes
Etekcity ESF17
0 Votes
Withings Body Scan

Guides 2

Articles 1

Let’s Get Started with Etekcity ESF17!

Let’s Get Started with Etekcity ESF17!

manuals.plus
manuals.plus

Files 1

All About Withings Body Scan

withings.com
withings.com

Reviews 0

The good, the bad, and the brutally honest.

Average Rating

Etekcity
Etekcity
Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity ESF17
0 / 5 0 Reviews
Withings
Withings
Withings Body Scan
Withings Body Scan
0 / 5 0 Reviews

Discussions 0

Thoughts, takes, and hot debates.

Awards 0

Only the best made it here.

Collections 0

Treasures You’ve picked. No fluff, all fun.

More Smart Scales 0

Unlock more awesome finds.

Other Etekcity Smart Scales 18

Other Withings Smart Scales 4

Etekcity ESF17
Etekcity
Etekcity
Etekcity ESF17
Withings Body Scan
Withings
Withings
Withings Body Scan
vs